• For latest updates on mobile SMS CRI to 52622

Trevor Chesterfield is a New Zealand born cricket writer/author and first-class umpire and has written on international cricket since 1958. He now resides in Sri Lanka.

More Columns

Archives

IPL can alienate a curious public from the game

Whatever way you look at it, media restrictions employed by the Indian Premier League over coverage by websites, such as CricketNext and other electronic outlets, of their event is setting a dangerous precedent.

It is about nefarious efforts to control the fourth estate and earning extra finances through a form of intimidation and where those in power can personally rake off extra moolah as part of the franchise deals.

If unchecked, what can also come from such bullying tactics is the veiled attempt by a paranoid establishment to censor a section of the media of their right to inform the public of what is taking place.

Next to be targeted by officialdom could be Test and the limited overs internationals. Maybe to the extent of banning television stations sports programmes from showing action clips of a day's play or games unless certain financial arrangement is made.

In which case, threats could later spread to screening packaged highlights of all games within the BCCI area of control.

It came as no surprise then how all media supply sources reacted to such high-handed tactics. It is at best a public relations disaster and the sooner it is exposed the better.

When a head honcho, such as IPL commissioner Lalith Modi acts as would someone two steps to the right of Genghis Khan, questions need to be asked of what is planned next?

The story is that all websites are excluded from match coverage at the venues. Should they want to run photographs they have to buy them from a United States-based organisation.

This is most interesting and it is understandable why the Editors Guild of India have raised objections and doubts about the accreditation conditions.

For a start, as there are no guarantees of the quality of photographs they are going to receive, why should they be forced to buy a product that could be inferior to their own cameraman's efforts?

And why, in this case, should the media be made to feel as would an unwelcome stepchild through such discriminatory stepfatherly tactics that are being practised here?

The IPL smugly refer to it as a question of 'safeguarding intellectual property rights' and as such their ownership of the franchises put at risk.

Well now, how they arrive at this erroneous conclusion would be interesting.

But it is typical of the muddled thinking that IPL have. One is selling off of photographic image rights to a foreign company to make money out of Indian media organisations. It is as bad as any hostile takeover bid of a journalist photographer's right to cover any event.

Not only that but the denial of the public to view action photographs on sites they visit is a form of censorship, whatever fancy glib phrase that Modi wants to trot out as a facile excuse.

The pity is that the Press Trust of India have agreed, under protest they claim to cover the tournament. No one can blame them as they are a national organisation and in a sense broken ranks.

But the others have not acceded to the demands placed in the way of other agencies by the BCCI surrogate, the IPL, and the latest dictator Modi.

By denying the public access to viewing images of T20 matches the BCCI and the IPL are in danger of alienating a curious public from the game.

In a career that now spans 55 years, and having watched and written about cricket in any number of countries, I have come across many intrusive types as Modi and learn to treat them as someone who is on a serious ego trip at the expense of others.

In Africa there is another Modi-style bully in Zimbabwe's Ozias Bvute, who rushes around in designer suits and a flashy imported German car while thousands of his countrymen and women suffer untold hardships in the daily food queues.

But this attempt by Modi and his gang to hijack the media's rights to take photographs without restriction can so easily backfire on the organisers if they use this as dummy run for future tours.

There is a whisper how the BCCI might attempt to enforce similar conditions on the India media before the Australian tour later this year. It is why such a culpable act as this one is setting a dangerous precedent for the future.

Total Comments: 9

Posted : By Raja

IPL Vs ICL :: Just a comparison!!!After watching IPL matches for the past 4 days, I felt that very few Indian players have made impression. Only known foreign stars are key performers after every IPL matches. Whereas in ICL, you hear new Indian players who either turn the match with their batting/bowling/fielding skills. Even though filding is not up to the mark in ICL from Indian side, they are better than the likes of Munaf Patel, Nehra etc.. No doubt ICL produces INDIAN stars, not the same on IPL.

Reply to this Comment

Posted : By Arthur

What Mr Modi and others need to realise in this 21st century, is that any form of cricketis not only about India and money. There are other people involved as well.These are the club players and officials in other countries. So many seem to forget this small fact, including the ICC as well as the BCCI.The game is for all people, not just a greedy few. Whether they are appreciated or not, the author is right in his comments.There is no happy medium, no middleground to travel through.The IPL is about greed and as such will eventually lose respect.

Reply to this Comment

Posted : By Sarita

When games of IPL progresses, some of the biggest players are going to fade away from INDIAN CRICKET. Similarly, some of the unknown faces are going to shine/take over INDIAN CRICKET. At the end of the day, senior players will be the losers.

Reply to this Comment

Posted : By Venkat Reddy

Actually the ipl is eliminating the public in more ways than one.The ticket prices are very very exorbitant in all stadiums.I have watched all the cricket that has been played in Chennai since 96 and the ticket prices this time are so exorbitant that it excludes the discerning fan.Sample this i would have to shell out close to 30$ for 3 hours. Correct me if i am wrong but its not so expensive to watch barca play at the camp nou!!

Reply to this Comment

Posted : By vik

This guy might me an egoist ,but he is quick to learn from the repercussions of his actions.So you will see all those problems getting resolved with passage of time.In fact ,it''s already happening.The stakes of this tournament are new for cricket and perhaps that''s why the creases still need some ironing, but once the tournament begins ,you can bet that Modi will look like a genius ,all because he got the right idea at the right time and acted on it.

Reply to this Comment

Feedback Form

Your Feedback

Name

Email

All the content posted in CricketNext.com Blogs section, unless specified otherwise, are made by CricketNext employees. The content posted in on CricketNext blog does not follow routine internal CricketNext reviews and editorial processes and should be considered only as the views and opinions of the writers themselves.